Why Most New Traders Fail – Lessons From the LIFFE Floor

By Martin Hills, founder of Financial eLearning and former LIFFE floor trader

Most people who start trading don’t fail because they picked the wrong strategy. They fail because they never built the foundations that keep a trader in the game long enough to get good.

I started on the LIFFE trading floor and later traded on the IPE, before moving to screen-based trading across interest rates, futures, oil and FX. Over the years I’ve watched a lot of traders come and go. The difference between the ones who lasted and the ones who didn’t was rarely talent.

The traders who lasted weren’t the ones chasing wins. They were the ones who understood market structure, position sizing, discipline, and how to survive when conditions changed.

1. They chase wins instead of managing risk

New traders tend to focus on how much they could make on a trade. Experienced traders focus first on how much they could lose – and whether they can survive it. On the floor, mistakes were immediate and accountability was unavoidable. You learned quickly that protecting your capital comes before growing it.

“Protecting your capital comes before growing it.”

2. They don’t understand position sizing

You can be right about the market and still lose money if your position is too big for your account. Position sizing is what lets you take a loss, learn from it and still be trading next week. It’s one of the least exciting parts of trading – and one of the most important.

3. They rely on tips, signals and unstructured learning

I’ve seen too many people come into trading without foundations, relying on tips, signals or unstructured learning. Some get lucky for a while. But markets eventually expose gaps in knowledge and discipline – and when that happens, the consequences are real.

4. They don’t understand market structure

Knowing how a market actually works – who the participants are, how prices are formed, why liquidity matters – gives context to every decision you make. Without it, a chart is just lines on a screen.

5. They lack discipline when conditions change

Markets don’t stay the same. I’ve traded through volatile periods, changing market structures and different trading models. The traders who survived weren’t the ones with a perfect system; they were the ones who stuck to their rules and adapted without panicking.

What to do instead

What made the biggest difference in my career wasn’t a single strategy or setup. It was education, structure and understanding risk. If you’re new to trading, start there:

• Learn how markets and trading roles actually work before risking money
• Make risk management and position sizing your first priority, not an afterthought
• Choose structured, recognised learning over tips and shortcuts
• Be honest about whether trading is right for you

That’s exactly why our Level 3 Certificate in Financial Trading exists – to build those foundations, and to help you decide whether trading is right for you at all. When you’re ready to go further, the Level 5 Diploma is the professional standard.

I don’t believe in shortcuts and I don’t believe in profit promises. I believe in education, structure and realism.

See the Level 3 CertificateRead learner reviews

Trading involves risk. No course can guarantee trading profits.